Economic Challenges
Economic Challenges: Despite claims of economic stability, Pakistan’s economy continues to face serious problems. The country may have moved away from an immediate crisis, but it is still far from recovery. The economy is like a patient who has left intensive care but still needs treatment.
Rising Poverty
Since 2024, Pakistan’s per capita income growth has remained close to zero. This is one of the slowest rates in South Asia. Short periods of economic growth have not lasted long. Most of this growth depends on imports. As a result, foreign reserves fall, and the country returns to the IMF for financial support. These conditions also keep economic growth low. Pakistan once performed better than many countries in the region in terms of income per person. Now, it risks falling behind them. As people’s incomes stop growing, poverty increases. Around 23 per cent of Pakistanis live in extreme poverty. This rate is much higher than India’s, even though both countries had almost similar levels in 2011.
Low Investment
Pakistan also spends too much on consumption and too little on investment. Around 82 per cent of its GDP goes towards consumption, while only 14 per cent goes towards investment. These figures are among the weakest in South Asia. India and China invest more than 30 per cent of their GDP. Their investments create jobs, improve industries, and increase production. Pakistan’s low investment limits job opportunities, technology, and exports. Industry also makes up a small part of the economy. Its share has remained close to one-fifth for more than 50 years. In comparison, industry contributes around one-quarter in India and Sri Lanka and one-third in Bangladesh.
Foreign Capital Dependence
Low investment slows economic growth, but Pakistan also fails to use its available capital properly. The country focuses on attracting foreign investors but ignores local investors and businesses. Foreign investment should create jobs, strengthen local industries, and bring more dollars into the country than it takes out. However, Pakistan mostly attracts foreign investment into local markets and domestic sectors. Later, foreign companies take their profits abroad, putting pressure on foreign reserves. Unlike other countries, Pakistan also depends on a few wealthy countries for financial support. It does not do enough to encourage local savings and private investment. As a result, the country faces a shortage of capital and remains dependent on foreign support.
Weak Export Performance
A shortage of investment in export industries also creates fewer jobs and reduces foreign earnings. In 1992, exports made up around 17 per cent of Pakistan’s GDP. Today, they barely reach 10 per cent. This is one of the lowest shares in South Asia, even lower than Afghanistan’s.
Pakistan also struggles with the quality of its exports. According to Harvard’s Economic Complexity Index, Pakistan ranks 89th out of 145 countries. This means the country produces and exports fewer complex and high-value products. As a result, Pakistani businesses face strong international competition but earn relatively little. Exports also fail to cover the cost of imports, creating large trade deficits.
Remittances Over Exports
Remittances from Pakistanis working abroad help reduce this financial gap. However, exports offer greater long-term benefits. They create jobs inside the country, keep families together, earn foreign exchange, and generate tax revenue. Remittances do not always create local jobs or directly increase tax collection. They also often support household spending instead of productive investment. Pakistan now receives almost as much money through remittances as it earns from exports. Sending workers abroad has become easier than selling more goods internationally. In comparison, India’s export earnings are six times higher than its remittances. Despite receiving remittances, Pakistan still faces large external deficits. These deficits often lead to financial crises when periods of growth come to an end.
Weak Tax System
Weak economic growth and poor tax collection also reduce government revenue. Pakistan collects taxes equal to only around 11 per cent of its GDP. This is one of the lowest rates in South Asia. Around half of its tax revenue comes from indirect taxes, which place a heavier burden on poor people. In 2021-22, this share was nearly two-thirds. The government continues to increase direct taxes on salaried workers and formal businesses, while several influential sectors pay relatively little tax. At the same time, government spending focuses more on running the system than improving the economy.
The federal government spends more than 90 paisas out of every rupee on routine expenses. It leaves only around five paisas for development projects. This leaves very little money for infrastructure, education, and economic improvement.
Rising Public Debt
Low tax revenue and high government spending force Pakistan to borrow more money. Public debt stands at around 73 per cent of GDP. This is lower than the debt levels of countries such as Japan and Singapore. However, Pakistan struggles to repay its debt. A large share of the federal budget goes towards interest payments. This leaves less money for public services and development. The government also borrows money to increase foreign reserves and meet regular expenses. Loans from the IMF and deposits from wealthy countries now exceed Pakistan’s previous record level of foreign reserves. These financial arrangements also bring difficult economic and political conditions.
Economic and Political Challenges
All these problems weaken the economy. Low investment slows growth and increases dependence on imports. This creates trade and budget deficits. The government then borrows more money, and rising interest payments reduce funds for development. This cycle continues and makes economic recovery even harder.
Pakistan’s economic problems also reflect its political system. Poor countries need a government that supports development and protects public welfare. However, Pakistan’s ruling system often serves powerful groups instead of ordinary citizens. The problem is not simply a lack of ability or experience. The government can hire skilled and qualified people to manage the economy. The deeper problem is a political system that protects the wealth and power of influential groups. Real economic progress could threaten their interests, so they often resist meaningful reforms.
Democratic Leadership
This problem has continued under different governments and political systems. Even authoritarian governments have sometimes achieved short-term economic growth. However, such growth has often created instability and damaged long-term progress. Pakistan already has many ideas and plans for economic improvement. What it lacks is honest leadership willing to put those ideas into action. Strong democracy and civilian control can help bring capable leaders into power and create a better future for the country.
Published in Dawn, 10th November 2026


Great job… the way articles are analyzed, it’s amazing.